Have an issue with your insurance?
Let everyone know!
Insurance companies are constantly reviewing us. Are we too old? Do we live in the wrong place? Is our credit score high enough? Well, now it's time to turn the tables. Do you charge too much? Will you pay my claim quickly? Is your coverage worse than it seems? We can review you too.
Top Insurance Companies
Ranked by Complaint Relativity
DOCTORS CO 0.00
PROASSURANCE 0.00
LIBERTY MUTUAL 0.00
APOLLO GLOBAL MGMT 26.19
SENTRY 32.66
BCBS OF MI 40.72
Pets Best - Pets best. I am very angry
So this may slightly be my fault but I need to vent and need options. I have had pets best for 2 years. My golden retriever blew her ACL and I took her to a surgeon and they confirmed it. The entire process took 5 months. I called pets best to see how to proceed, they said to pay the bill and then send everything to them. So I did.
They just came back and said that they will not reimburse me because I don’t wait 6 months to have the surgery. WTF!!! and why would you not tell me when I called to ask how to proceed?!?
Am I just out of luck? Or do you think that this is worth fighting? I am out $7k now. This is why I had pet insurance in the first place!!!
Fetch - Fetch (formerly Petplan) Canada first claim
I originally signed up for Petplan Canada because we had it for my cat in the UK and they were pretty good.
Signed my cat up here in Canada when she was about 7 years old. A few years ago they got bought by Fetch who definitely seemed a bit dodgy based on the sudden price increase and trying to sell preventative care packages that are a total scam.
Made my first claim this summer (she's now ~12?) when my cat suddenly got very sick from a hairball. She had a lot of tests including X-ray blood test, and ultrasound at the emergency vet. My Fetch policy at the time was about $133/month ($1500/year) with 90% coverage, max deductible ($650). They reimbursed $2500 of the $3500 without any resistance for which I was pleasantly surprised. I just got the email for the policy renewal and it has gone up from $1500/year to $2500/year. Some of that would be from my cat being one year older.
Embrace - Embrace pet insurance is a rip off
I recently took my cat in for a mouth surgery to remove an infected tooth. The bill came out to be almost $600. Since I wasn’t enrolled in the wellness rewards it only covered $108 after a $200 deductible. When I pay $130 a month for both of my cats. When I first got this it was $60 for both of them and it has now doubled over the years to only cover a 1/6th of my cats surgery? I can’t believe it.
Any recommendations for any pet insurance for my cats? They are pretty healthy overall indoor cats, I just like to keep this for my peace of mind in case anything happened but with this recent increase year and now this, I can’t justify embrace.
Progressive - Wear and tear vs. unnatural wear due to damage
My wife was driving and was hit in the rear driver panel and part of the rear tire in a hit and run. The car was drivable so it was not towed. The impact caused the tire to toe out however.
For context, I had the specific tire that was hit replaced maybe two months ago. That being said, BOTH rear tires were worn down to bald and wire showing in some areas.
Progressive has deemed that only the drivers side tire is eligible for coverage because it caused sidewall damage and that the tires are bald because it is a performance vehicle. They are also saying that a single tire being improperly aligned/toed would not cause any additional wear to the other tires.
Do I have any options as far as getting them to cover the passenger tire? Is there a magic phrase or wording I need to use? I understand that a new tire is only around $250 to mount and balance but I feel like this is something the insurance should cover given the circumstances.
Wawanesa Insurance - Update: Wawanesa Insurance Cancellation – Broker Responded, But Now I’m Facing $2,500+ Upfront Cost to Switch
Hey everyone,
This is a follow-up to my earlier post about trying to cancel my Wawanesa auto insurance (I’m the guy paying $750/month for a commercial plan meant for Uber Eats, which I barely do anymore). My regular broker had gone silent for a while, but I finally got in touch.
Here’s the update:-
My broker confirmed I can cancel the policy early.
However, he says I’ll have to pay two months' worth of premium upfront as a penalty — that’s around $1,500.
The new policy I’m eyeing (with TD Bank) is non-commercial and about $450/month, but they also require 2 months paid upfront to start coverage — that’s another $900.
So basically, to switch policies, I’d need to cough up $2,400–$2,500 upfront, just to get out of this $750/month cycle.
Now I’m stuck asking myself:
Is it even worth switching, or should I just suck it up and keep paying monthly till my current policy ends in November?
Will I even save enough in the long run to justify the upfront hit?
Has anyone else dealt with a similar situation — switching from commercial to personal auto insurance mid-term?
Any creative options or negotiation tips I could try with either Wawanesa or TD?
I’m still trying to be financially smart here — just don’t want to end up spending more just to spend less later. Appreciate all your input!
FedEx - PSA lost cards to grade
I was part of a bulk submission of cards. We insured them for shipping with FedEx for $26,000. FedEx deliver the box but it was kind of damaged. PSA signed for the box then decided that they were gonna refuse delivery and return to sender. PSA just then lost the box. PSA is taking responsibility but offering a low ball replacement value to people. For example, I had vintage cards and I've done the insurance about $200 and they are offering $10 a card. Is there any recourse?
Optum Bank - Unable to use money in DCFSA
So, I was terminated in May of 2024 where I have a DCFSA account.
When I went to call Optum Bank, they said the employer allows 3 months of grace period (to August 2024) then terminates the account. Optum account follows this, and does not allow reimbursements from terminated accounts.
It looks like I'll lose this money.
Any thoughts?
Figo - Avoid Figo
Terrible company. Find any excuse, especially bogus "pre-existing conditions" to avoid any reimbursement. Avoid and look elsewhere unless you want to waste time on the phone appealing denials to no avail.
HealthyPaws - HealthyPaws: Insane Premium Increases Since Moving to Pennsylvania
Do they not regulate, or loosely regulate, pet insurance premiums in Pennsylvania? I started a string on a cat Facebook group asking people to note their cats age, healthypaws premium, and city/state. To my surprise, someone with a cat in NYC at a similar age was paying way less than me.
For reference, my cat just turned 19 and my ~60 day notice says my premium is going up from ~$380/month to ~$650/month. I don't think I have the option to switch insurance providers since my cat has a lot of health issues we are managing. Most plans do not cover pre-existing conditions.
Can people post their healthypaws premiums below if they own a cat, inclusive of the age of your cat, city and state?
For those who live in Pennsylvania, are you also seeing crazy increases? If there is a pattern of Pennsylvania being the outlier here, I can draft a letter to the Department of Insurance and the Attorney General.
Note: My premiums for my cat when she was about 17 and in Phoenix, Arizona, were ~$150/month.
American Family - Overhead&Profit Dilemma
For context, this is in reference to a claim with American Family homeowners policy in AZ.
Long story short, we had a claim for our shower 6 months ago. Contractor gave estimate for $8700 (ish) and I was paid $7700 (ish). Our responsibility is our $1000 deductible. Our contractor is auditing our account to make sure our final bill is correct and he’s saying that O&P was only included on a few line items and not all of the line items. He thinks we are owed more money because it wasn’t properly calculated. The adjuster is saying that O&P is only paid when 3 or more trades are used and we had more than 3, but somehow there is a disconnect and the adjuster is stonewalling him. I don’t know how to approach this situation. We’ve used this contractor before on a previous claim years prior so I trust him and his expertise about insurance claims and what’s “right” and not fraud. And if this is how he deals with other claims, how is it that American family is causing such a headache? I just don’t know what to do. He also thinks that if he was dealing with an experienced adjuster this wouldn’t even have been a discussion and it would have been handled correctly. Any insight would be great. Thank you.
Make A Complaint
Loading...