We've had several years with Amica, they've been great. However the new rate even with a 1.5k deductible is a lot. If you've got a good non-first tier insurer that we can trust, I'd like a recommendation.

Good afternoon, I was in a car accident in December, 2024. OP was found at fault within 24 hours of the claim being submitted, however, it took over 2 months to have my car repaired. My insurance company only covered 30 days of rental coverage and I paid out of pocket around $600 for the additional days needed. I submitted a claim to have that reimbursed and my insurance company stated they are filing an Arbitration. Is this usual for this case scenario? How long do these usually take to resolve? State Farm is OP's insurance and I have Amica.

I was just notified by Amica they will be dropping me in June due to having 2 previous claims in 2022 and 2023. Both were from individual pipe bursts Amica fixed. I’ve resolved further issues by paying out of pocket to repipe the entire house in 2024. Amica was aware of the re-piping but was still not interested in keeping me on. I do not live in a fire zone. I’ve been told no by several insurance companies stating because i’ve had water damage claims, I’m ineligible for their coverage, even though I’ve completely repiped my home last year. I have tried working with two different independent insurance brokers, both haven’t had success. One found a home policy for $18,000/year. Not including auto and umbrella. I was paying $4500 all in. Anyone have any luck getting coverage in a similar situation as me, with previous claims? I’d love to avoid CFP and DIC if possible. Thanks

I just had a Total Loss on my home which was insured by Amica Mutual. Almost all reputable insurance carriers pay out the face value of the policy. Amica decided to use an obscure New York loophole to "AVERAGE" out what THEY feel I should get instead of what I paid for. They offered me less than 50% of THEIR ADJUSTOR'S replacement cost with the balance paid out after "THEIR REVIEW AND APPROVAL".