My roof is 13 years old (original to the house), and recently had some wind damage after a storm. I started a claim in 2019 with my previous insurance company (after a hail storm) and was denied a replacement because apparently someone has been on the roof with a hammer or something attempting to mimic hail damage, so it was determined to be vandalism. The new damage is due to wind, but the vandalism is still present. I’m told that at least the back slope (if not the whole thing) needs replaced. Should I file a claim or just pay for the replacement out of pocket?