Have an issue with your insurance?
Let everyone know!
Insurance companies are constantly reviewing us. Are we too old? Do we live in the wrong place? Is our credit score high enough? Well, now it's time to turn the tables. Do you charge too much? Will you pay my claim quickly? Is your coverage worse than it seems? We can review you too.
Top Insurance Companies
Ranked by Complaint Relativity
DOCTORS CO 0.00
PROASSURANCE 0.00
LIBERTY MUTUAL 0.00
APOLLO GLOBAL MGMT 26.19
SENTRY 32.66
BCBS OF MI 40.72
Progressive - Progressive Diminished Value Claim
Progressive offered me $750 for diminished value based on costs they incurred for the claim. They did not even consider the actual cash value of the vehicle. For context, this is in Texas and the claim was made on the other parties insurance and I was found at no fault. The car is a brand new BMW M2 and the total repairs estimated around $4-$5k including labor. There’s definitely more than $750 of diminished value since this is a performance car and now has an incident on the car fax.
According to the representative, they are not willing to offer more even if I get an estimate of the actual cash value. Do I have any options outside of just accepting what I was given?
Mercury - Mercury or Progressive condo insurance in California? How does one even know which company's reliable with so many varying personal accounts?
I currently have condo insurance with Mercury, but their dwelling coverage isn't high enough, so I asked my Mercury agent how much it would cost to buy more dwelling coverage. He didn't respond for almost 3 weeks, which was concerning and surprising because when he were wooing me, he responded within hours. I shopped around and got a slightly lower quote from Progressive. The low cost is nice, but I'd rather go with the company that'll actually pull through in case something happens.
I read a bunch of reddit posts about both Progressive and Mercury, but the experiences all seem so varied and I have no idea who's the most reliable. Sadly, they both seem kind of shitty, but we're strapped for options in California and I can't find anyone else who will take me. I've looked on various insurance ranking websites, but so many sources contradict each other. (For example, Mercury won best insurer in 2021 with JD Power but they have a low star ranking for customer satisfaction with NerdWallet.)
With so much contradictory and anecdotal information, how does one even choose a home insurance company? It doesn't seem like there's a general consensus on reddit either about one company over the other.
Nationwide - Nationwide dropped us - help!
I have a 4-year-old French Bulldog, and we previously used Nationwide for her pet insurance. Unfortunately, we just found out they dropped our policy without any reason. I have been looking around for other pet insurance companies but feel frustrated by the pre-existing condition coverage. We signed up for trupanion but they want records of our last 2 years and my pet has a few things in the notes that I think will totally screw us going forward like itchy paws, a hurt pack, and previous GI bugs/UTIs. Has anyone found a good insurance company that will not be so harsh about not covering pre-existing conditions? Thanks in advance for the recommendations!
MetLife - Should I switch over to Metlife?
Not your standard switching question, honestly. My partner got a job that offers metlife so our 2 dogs are eligible to switch over to metlife from our current insurance. We have petsbest currently. I already checked and there's no concerns about it being my partners work (and only I am currently on my the petsbest insurance). I spoke with metlife on the phone extensively so I can switch anytime basically, i'm mostly wondering reasons I might want to stay vs not.
Both my dogs have quite a few medical conditions and Petsbest has generally done due diligence. I insured my pit mix in Jan 2022 when I got him and they've covered almost everything. (Annual premiums: 2022 was 460, 2023 was 560, 2024 was 725, and this year was 1032. 250 deductible, 90% reimbursement, unlimited level). They denied only one claim. They denied something and considered it alternative. Even tho it's supplied by a teaching hospital, has studies, and the doctor wrote a huge letter explaining why it was the only option for my dog (my dog has multiple concurrent co-morbidities). They still said no. I asked before hand but they wouldn't pre approve and when I said I was concerned bc it was a big bill they just said I could always appeal. I did, and even with a super detailed letter, nothing. However, he has MANY medical conditions- allergies (on apoquel, immunotherapy, regular derm visits), anxiety (on a couple medications), hip dysplasia/OA and IVDD (on meds and may need surgery). So they've more than paid for his medical conditions.
Second dog we adopted in Sept 2024 and she was a 500 deductible, 90% reimbursement and 816/yr. Ended up in 12k in bills between emergency surgery, post op complications and follow up labs. They've paid up. We had to appeal one thing but successfully this time.
Petsbest has been fine and paid and processed, though slow, which is fine.
I'm mostly considering metlife as both dogs are on prescription foods and metlife will cover wellness care. I could get both dogs annual dentals (which i always planned to do, but was considering pushing it out to 1.5 years out when I'll get a better dental price at a new employer), get tick and flea prevention covered! (200 for one dog, 220 for the other). The prescription foods for the dogs run me about 70 every 1.5-2 months. I'm seriously considering it but feel like there may be something I'm missing. The company confirmed they'd cover rx food even tho petsbest doesnt, btw. Same with dental cleanings.
These were their quotes and I was planning to go with the most expensive one, tbh:
* Family plan: 250 deductible, 90%, unlimited was 2108.92 without wellness
* With wellness: 2938.44
* Family plan: 500 deductible, 90%, unlimited was 1783.25 without wellness
* With wellness: 2469.98
* Family plan: 250 deductible, 80%, unlimited
* with wellness: 2047.84
* Family plan: 500 deductible, 80%, unlimited
* with wellness: 1728.52
Would love any insight and opinions.
Fidelity - 403b fix - how to close - summer savings leeched in fees
A friend is in a fix - seeking to get some expert's thoughts here:
Is there an option to close 403b? who to ask? Should it be the company (Fid in this case) or the benefits team.
unfortunately he worked for a short term in a school summer position and saved 400$ in 403b. did not know that there will be a fee of 70$ charged every year ( ridiculous amount ). No longer doing the job but will be a student another few years.
Fidelity says benefits has to terminate the employee status and only then funds can be taken or account closed.
benefits say they can't terminate until he remains a student, even if not doing the summer job.
The balance now is 330$ :( He's quite upset understandably.
Pretty soon will come 0 if no action taken
What are his options?
Fidelity chat isn't helpful and say cannot close since he is still active in status.
It is a mistake hoping to save, without realizing the fee unfortunately.
Any thoughts or suggestions?
Thanks
Insurance Company - Should I sell my house for a loss or tough it out?
As the title says I'm in a little bit of a rough spot, and am looking for some outside advice. I moved across country for a better paying job and saved up for a house. After putting over 50k down on a house priced at 240 with about an acre of land. I thought I did okay, I knew the house was a little older and would need some updating but I thought I was saving money in the long run and that it would be a good investment considering the area.
Went through a realtor, had the house inspected, did all the normal things. But immediately things went wrong. Within two weeks of owning the house, the detached garage had a major leak and I had to get the roof replaced. The inspector refunded us our money but said that he wasn't liable beyond that. Several lawyers told me there wasn't a good chance I'd get anything and it would just be cheaper to eat the cost of the roof. So I did.
Had to replace almost every appliance and toilet in the home because they all started to fall apart within the first six months. Again just figured it was my bad luck and there wasn't anything I could do.
Fast forward to a month ago and just before the year anniversary of buying the home, the entire finished basement flooded. Insurance said since it was ground water that it wasn't covered. Turns out there were some big foundation issues that I have now spent over 20 grand to fix. Again insurance said that foundational issues are considered " normal wear and tear" and so not covered.
After starting the repair process on that I've discovered a whole slew of other issues with the home that was hidden behind finished walls. And with my never ending good luck, I had a gas leak in my furnace that I found the other morning. I have turned the gas off to the furnace until I can get someone to repair it.
The problem is I am already well over 100k cash into this house and I've only had it a year. Idk how much longer I can keep this up considering I'm basically bled dry and I haven't even fixed anything beyond the foundation yet. The wife wants to sell the house after we fix it all up and just get out, but I'm worried that we won't recoup anywhere close to what we have in and will be stuck back in apartments again.
I'm not sure what to do or how to move past this place. Has anyone been in similar situations? Is there light at the end of this tunnel or should I bail and just accept the loss of all that money?
Any advice would be appreciated
Travelers - POC Information
Hey Team, if I get 'ghosted' by an adjuster how would one find their manager's contact information so I can send them an email? This is for Travelers in the Mid-Atlantic Region USA.
Still haven't gotten any reimbursement for my personal property after a fire... and several attempts to contact them.
UnitedHealthcare - Insurance company won't provide cost estimate. Neither will provider. Who's lying?
My Dr wants to enroll me in a weight loss support group program. I have a high deductible plan with UHC so I will essentially be paying out of pocket until I meet my annual deductible. Dr's office asked me to call my insurance to check if it's covered, and they told me the billing codes. UHC said it's covered, but the cost ranges from $30-250 (per 20 minute session) depending on what the provider charges. They will pay 90% after I meet my deductible. They say that they don't know how much a particular provider will charge. I asked my Dr what they would charge, and they said the price is set by the insurance company. Who is lying?
Progressive - Home policy will be dropped due to soon to be demolished garage roof.
I was just informed that my progressive home policy will be dropped due to the condition of my detached garage's roof. They want to see a signed contract to demolish the structure or replace the roof within "the immediate future."
The problem is, we are working with a contractor and engineer to plan and permit a new 2 story garage/living space in its place and that process will likely take at least a year before breaking ground, maybe more.
It would be a huge waste of money to re roof a structure that will be demolished and would be a huge inconvenience to demolish the structure over a year early.
Does anyone know the magic words to say to impress upon them that the structure will be torn down. Or is there any way they can exclude that structure from my policy? Or am I SOL and should start shopping for a new policy?
Erie - Progressive Direct
I currently have Erie no recent accidents or traffic violations. I did switch to an EV which I guess triggered the recent price increases. My annual premium went from $925 to over $1700 for 2 vehicles. I did a quote at progressive direct and the annual price is about $500 less with the same coverages except I didn't include the accident forgiveness or deductible savings bank. Is it a really bad decision to switch from Erie to Progressive? The monthly price option for the two actually saves me about $720/year. Am I missing something that I'm overlooking?
Make A Complaint
Loading...