Have an issue with your insurance?
Let everyone know!
Insurance companies are constantly reviewing us. Are we too old? Do we live in the wrong place? Is our credit score high enough? Well, now it's time to turn the tables. Do you charge too much? Will you pay my claim quickly? Is your coverage worse than it seems? We can review you too.
Top Insurance Companies
Ranked by Complaint Relativity
DOCTORS CO 0.00
PROASSURANCE 0.00
LIBERTY MUTUAL 0.00
APOLLO GLOBAL MGMT 26.19
SENTRY 32.66
BCBS OF MI 40.72
MetLife - They have been dragging their feet from…
They have been dragging their feet from the very start of our FIRST claim with them. It has been 20 days and several emails plus a direct letter to them asking what they keep saying 10 days for a claim to be processed. It is double that now. This is not a large claim. With the results received from this small claim, I am worried that if we had a major claim this would be the result. We have two dogs insured with them and will be looking elsewhere for a reputable pet insurance company.
Fetch Canada - Not consistent! Adjusters make issues out of nothing.
I have submitted 2 claims through Fetch insurance. The first claim went through fine - no problems. The second claim came back flagged because an exam note from 3 years prior for my dog's annual vaccination appointment did not state her health status. Side note: this was the same medical record I used for her first claim that had no issues.
Obviously if nothing was noted on her exam notes, nothing was wrong with her.
They nit pick on big claims once you've paid your deductible - I called customer service and they were rude so I asked to cancel. I was transferred to another agent to cancel and she was confused to why this was even a problem - she reached out to the adjusters and stated there was no issues with my medical records and that if there was no negative notes for that appointment then to assume that she was healthy (common sense). If there are more issues with this claim, I will be cancelling. This claim has been pointlessly dragged out for weeks.
To edit my post: the first agent I spoke to wasn’t per se rude, but very dismissive to the point I wanted to cancel and was happy to assist with that. The second agent I spoke to was very understanding and talked me out of cancelling.
Update: edited my review from 1 to 3 stars. They were very prompt with processing my claim after the vet called them and said there’s nothing more to submit. I am hoping going forward I won’t have the same issues with her medical records if I need to submit future claims.
Embrace - Good day!
Good day!
I'm new and trying to figure it all out what it helps w and how it works and benefit for me and prince.
I'll see in time.
Thanks again
ASPCA - Asked me to pay back my reimbursed claims
ASPCA has been great... until last week... when they reached out to me saying they had made a mistake a few months back and "accidentally" approved several claims that I had over 6+ months ago that they now believe were potentially caused by a preexisting condition. Which is not the case. And they are now asking me to repay them over $600 in the next 30 days from reimbursements they made to me literally between 4 months ago and 10 months ago. Absolutely absurd and unacceptable. I am good about not submitting claims that are truly for preexisting conditions, so this is just very disappointing. Not to mention - I don't have the $600 that they reimbursed me a year ago?! I would understand more if it were from last month, but there should be a limitation on how far in advance they can ask for money back.
MetLife - definitely not for exotic pets
There are very few exotic pet insurances out there, and I was told metlife was the exception. I was told wrong. I have had multiple complications and misinformation about my policy and what it covers from the moment I got my quote. I was told my policy would cover spay/neuter over the phone, but now I am told it isn't covered, and I am out 4,000 dollars with no assistance.
(I have a rex rabbit btw)
Nationwide - DON'T DO IT!
So I saw all the reviews and I applied anyways some where good. Well Was I wrong! I have 3 cats and 2 dogs one was 9 at the time. Well when it came to renew the older Dog was going to be 10 years old and more money and that was ok but the last 2months before the date they should be taken the money out They took out more money then they should have. I asked them about the first time and they said nothing and the 2nd time they said I was sent a letter that before the big payments would start I would need to pay a deposit why I have been with you all for a year. I asked to cancel all 5 animal's I had with them....Talk about biting the hand that feeds you! No one asked if I would like to talk to a manager and I can only assume they wouldn't care as well.! Then I asked if the money would be put back in my account they said yes. Well Not there yet it was 3 days late I had to call back and they stated it takes 8 days for this to happen WTH they have no problem taken your money but can't give it back as fast as they can take it out that's CRAP! I have to say they are not flexible as well they don't care if you live check to check like the rest of the world! I'm going back to HEALTH PAWS I never had a problem with them! I think all insurance is a scam and to fill pockets for the big people but man when your pets get hurt they should be there! I have to say HEALTH PAWS was there for my older Dog I should of never left! I did leave because I was going to put the new cats on as well and Health Paws was a lot don't for get I live check to check with the rest of the world. So going back to them with the Dogs maybe I will fine a place for the cats and this time I will do my research well for them!
Pets Best - Better to not have insurance
They hide everything in the fine print. Their accident and illness plan doesn’t cover the emergency exam portion of your emergency visit which is often half of the price of taking your pet to an emergency vet. They also only pay $150 towards spay/neuter and won’t cover anything that is labeled as pre-op such as medications or the pre-op visit, even though they advertise covering spay/neuter. We paid $71/month for 9 months with a new puppy (lots of exams, vaccines, office visits, neuter, and emergency visits) and got reimbursed a whopping $200 total in that time because nothing is covered or even counts toward your deductible. It makes more sense to not have this insurance.
Fetch - Mirroring a review I have seen below
Mirroring a review I have seen below, they have zero interest in helping our animals…zero, extremely challenging to deal with to get our pup the help he needed and we couldn’t get a reimbursement at all for a general health check which had been included in our plan.
The worst for me is, we just got charged an increased price without further notification of said increase or that a renewal was going to occur.
This company is essentially a money grab and using celebrity vets to pump up their name! Shame on you.
Like any other insurance company it is only just about taking money and nothing about helping. They filled me full of shit about ‘waiving’ non coverage periods when you get seen within certain periods of coverage beginning…I was lied to.
The response I got below is utter nonsense, if they gave a crap they would do the right thing and not just take money without ever showing a willingness to care for animals. WILL BE CANCELLING! And they charged an expired card
MetLife - Although the reimbursement timeframe…
Although the reimbursement timeframe states 10 days, there is no guarantee when you’ll receive your reimbursement. I’ve submitted a claim on 1/09/25 and as of today, 1/28/25, I have not received my reimbursement. Highly unacceptable as this is the second time this has happened and I’ve only submitted three claims. I will be canceling and switching to Fido.
Pets Plus Us - Avoid This Company – Terrible Experience
This insurance company has been incredibly frustrating to deal with. They don’t respond to emails, even though they recommend this as a way to communicate. When you call, they give you the runaround, and the information from one manager contradicts what another told me just days earlier.
I paid premiums for six months to insure my two healthy cats. Both have all necessary international documentation, including microchips, passports, vaccines, and veterinary certificates. After six months, I took one of my cats to the vet for an ear infection and advice on food, as the cat had vomited three times in one week. The veterinarian explicitly noted in the medical file that vomiting is “not unusual.” The issue resolved entirely after switching food, which is also documented in the file.
Despite this, the company claimed I hadn’t provided the “correct” medical documents—even though the documents I provided fully complied with the requirements outlined in their User Guide. I sent all required documentation when I enrolled and clearly stated, “If you need anything else, please contact me.” They never contacted me. Instead, six months later, they retroactively canceled my policy and promised a refund. It’s now been over three weeks, and I still haven’t received my money.
To make matters worse, they created new policies for my cats and labeled everything from that vet visit—including notes from the anamnesis (not even a diagnosis)—as pre-existing conditions. For example, they listed:
“Vomiting / Emesis and associated conditions”
Seriously? Vomiting is a natural behavior for cats (e.g., regurgitating hairballs). It’s also a symptom of countless possible conditions. By labeling it a pre-existing condition, they’re essentially trying to exclude everything.
This company doesn’t provide insurance—they provide excuses to deny coverage. Avoid them at all costs.
Make A Complaint
Loading...